Bob Frye

It wouldn’t be fair to call Hamilton Lake near Wellsboro unloved. Tioga County does a good job of maintaining it and the park around it for the benefit of local residents, and the Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission stocks it annually with trout, something that draws big crowds in spring.
But to call it underappreciated? You could make that argument.

Just as limiting is that much of this natural, 90-acre lake is rimmed by private residences. You can fish it from a boat – that’s your best option – and there is one Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission launch on the western shore. Even it only has space for 10 vehicles and trailers, though.

There are a lot of stocked trout lakes around Pennsylvania that are full of bass. There are bass lakes that also support walleyes.
But lakes that hold all three – trout, bass and walleyes – in catchable numbers? And big sizes? Those are scarce. This is one, though.

We’ve heard this story before, haven’t we? A routine investigation of a lake popular with local anglers reveals a dam in need of substantial repair. The state steps in, the lake goes down and its fish go away.
Better days, we’re told – and perhaps better fishing – lie ahead. That was the tale when Gouldsboro Lake, the 250-acre impoundment that lies within 2,800-acre Gouldsboro State Park in Monroe and Wayne counties, was drawn down in 2007.

You usually can recognize the people who bought the first shares of stock in Apple computers and then held onto them long term, as the company morphed into a technological behemoth. They’re the ones on exclusive beaches sipping fancy drinks.
Such are the rewards of getting in on the ground floor of a big opportunity. Fishing Marshall Lake in Allegheny County, today, will not provide that kind of return on investment in a year, or 10 years, or ever. So hang on to your day job.

Shoving off in my canoe, we circled Acme Dam clockwise, tossing soft plastic lures – worms mostly – and letting them sink to the bottom.
That never takes long in most spots. This 24-acre lake that serves as the centerpiece of Chestnut Ridge Park in Westmoreland County is only about 3.5 feet deep, on average. But on this night, they never even got down that far. Largemouth bass kept intercepting them first.

The Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission’s list of “best” places in the state to fish for northern pike does not include Memorial Lake.
That’s not the indictment you might think. The truth is, the list doesn’t include many places at all. Just three waters are deemed worthy of recognition. Far more waters around Pennsylvania hold at least enough pike to make things interesting, though. Memorial Lake, the 84-acre water at the center of Memorial Lake State Park in Lebanon County, is one of them.