One of the big takeaways from the recent “shared services” study by the Wildlife Management Institute was that savings and efficiency could be realized by eliminating redundancy within the Pennsylvania Game Commission and Fish & Boat Commission.
That seems somewhat obvious, but will it happen?
In my opinion, it all depends to what degree the Legislature gets involved. So far, I’ve seen two responses from legislators that would take the debate in different directions.
The most concerning – and perhaps pointless – approach is the one being championed by state Rep. Anita Kulik, who is the majority chair of the House Game and Fisheries Committee.
On Sept. 21, Kulik released a co-sponsorship memo for intent to introduce a resolution directing the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee to take what WMI already did and … study it more.
Keep in mind, the concept of sharing services or even merging the Pennsylvania Game Commission and Fish & Boat Commission has been studied by this very committee several times over the years, most recently in 2003 and 2014.
So having the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee do yet another study on redundancy between the two agencies seems a bit redundant as well.
MORE COVERAGE FROM PENNSYLVANIA OUTDOOR NEWS:
Notes off a soiled cuff: Pennsylvania hunter ed instructors aging out
Could Centre County’s Penn’s Cave be a Pennsylvania state park? Decision up in the air
How will fall colors fare in Pennsylvania? Early drought may impact the southeast

In her memo, Kulik said she’d like the committee to look at any statutory changes that would be needed to combine services. That part is fine, but to bog down the potential benefits of sharing services with yet another legislative study is pointless.
The WMI was already paid $49,000 to study the matter and make recommendations, so the work is already done.
Yet there’s another part of the process in which legislators can help, and it deals with transparency. Since the WMI report was released, it generated a lot of questions from hunters and anglers. But when it comes to answers, where do they turn? It’s not like hunters and anglers can call up WMI and ask them about the findings.
Instead of conducting another study on the matter, legislators can hold a hearing with WMI officials and leaders of both agencies. They can ask the questions that their hunter and angler constituents are asking them, and get answers, all in front of the public.
A transparent format that yields substantive answers will give hunters and anglers direct insight into what’s being recommended and where we go from here.
Skip the study and let’s get to the root of the issue. Will Pennsylvania continue to be the only state in the nation without merged game and fish agencies? Will services be shared, and if so which ones? When will it happen? How will it affect license buyers and, most importantly, the resource?
Conducting a study on top of a study doesn’t give hunters and anglers the answers they deserve.
Especially this time around, and here’s why: The wording in Kulik’s memo indicates to me that she’s already going into the study proposal with a bias. Here’s what she wrote:
“Furthermore, I want to make it clear that I remain opposed to any measure that would seek to merge the commissions, or reduce or remove the independent management provided for under the PFBC’s and PGC’s boards of commissioners.”
How can a fair and all-encompassing study even be done when the person calling for it is handcuffing the process before it even starts?
And why is Kulik so threatened about the mere mention of a merger in the first place that she has to single it out in her memo?
The only way to conduct an honest, accurate study is to not place boundaries on it beforehand. Let every factor – including a merger – be considered and scrutinized.
It all just seems odd to me that since the WMI report was released the mere mention of the word “merger” has become taboo to some.
I’m not advocating for a merger of our game and fish agencies, but if we’re going to talk about sharing services and consolidation it has to be in the discussion. And if legislators like Kulik are vehemently opposed to a merger, they need to tell us why it’s a bad idea and won’t work.
Ultimately, this is why hunters and anglers need transparency, and not another redundant study aimed at solving redundancy.



2 thoughts on “Tom Venesky: Pennsylvania’s hunters, anglers need answers, not another study”
Kulik has already proven that she is an obstructionist and a Game Commission lapdog, so why would this be any different. Unfortunately, Dave Maloney – the Republican minority chair got nosed out when the Democrats gained control of the House, and it’s been a disaster ever since!
Hypocrisy. Spend more money on studies because the people we vote in to do a job, want to have somebody else do it for them. Cross training personnel will take away the specialized Men and Women who know their jobs inside out. Stay the course with the PGC & PFBC.