Deer hunters always seem up for a good debate, which these days is often capable of deteriorating into a full-blown argument, especially if it involves Facebook or message boards.
Maybe it’s always been that way, but I don’t recall disputes over deer management, deer harvest and other things whitetail related being nearly as venomous before the arrival of social media.
I just wish there was a little more honesty involved on both sides.
Sure, quality deer management, for instance, creates a better buck-to-doe ratio if properly implemented; that’s simply a fact.
But let’s inject a little honesty here: while trimming the antlerless herd is all part of the plan, the real deal is about growing mature bucks. Big bucks, both in body and antlers. I’m fine with that, and along the way I’ve even benefited from it in the form of an outstanding 10-point some 15 years ago.
Conversely, I wish, too, the “you can’t eat the horns” fraternity would admit, as they’re dragging out a Keystone State five-pointer, they’d much rather be putting a tag on a 12-point – which, by the way, would fill their freezer more than the buck they took.
Don’t get me wrong; I’m not shaming their kill. But neither should they snicker at the hunter who passes on smaller bucks in hopes of encountering one that might look great on their wall. That’s their choice.
Me? I just hunt and enjoy my time afield every year. I realize that window is closing, and in reality could close abruptly – you just never know. I’m hoping I have many more seasons ahead, but I know, too, the calendar is undefeated.
MORE WHITETAIL COVERAGE FROM OUTDOOR NEWS:
How temperature changes cause the wind to move, and what that means to whitetail hunters
Wild game left in your freezer? Great recipes to try before refilling this fall
I may not be as excited for the upcoming deer season as a 12-year-old Steve Piatt, but I am looking forward to it. My archery – full disclosure, crossbow – season is really my time in the tree.
After that, I become a de facto hunting guide for my wife, Paula, who has never warmed to the crossbow and instead awaits the firearms season, dialing in her 7mm-08 and .30-06 and shifting me to field-dressing and dragging duties, although she’s making the transition to wielding a knife when a deer is down.
And for me, every season is different. Although it’s a rare year that I pass on a legal buck, there have been seasons when I did hold out in an area where a good one has been seen on one of our cameras.
Too, every season I debate as to whether to take a doe early, and then hedge again later in the season, knowing a buck could be close behind.
Paula and I have plenty of tags; more than our freezers can handle. But we’ve outlined our plan to donate some through the state’s Hunters Sharing the Harvest program, as well as to a couple of non-hunting friends who are hooked on venison.
In our hunting area, the herd definitely needs to be thinned. Last week on our evening drive around the hill we jokingly call our “There are No Deer in Pennsylvania” tour, we counted more than 100.
That’s not unusual, which I see as a product of many pockets of posted land where whitetails slip in when responding to hunting pressure.
And many hunters simply don’t shoot antlerless deer for a number of reasons, some of them quite legitimate. Early in the season they simply don’t want to deal with a downed doe in the heat, and they may be patterning a buck on a food source and don’t want to impact their spot.
Later, they may be hoping a buck may be following a doe. Too, I often stop short of pulling the trigger on an antlerless deer in fear of downing a button buck; I’ve been wrong before. That’s just being honest.
The checkerboard of available hunting land and parcels that are off limits to hunting is, in my mind, what has led to the griping among many hunters that the deer herd has been decimated. The deer, in many cases, are there; the hunters just can’t get to them.
Too often I hear a longtime hunter spitting fire: “I’ve been sitting on this stump for 30 years and don’t see nearly as many deer as I used to.”
You probably shouldn’t be seeing as many as in years past when whitetails were eating the forest down to the dirt floor. And maybe it’s time to find another stump.
Things change, even from one year to the next, let alone over a period of decades. Land use, development and mast crop availability all play a role.
And while I’m being honest, I confess my hunting season doesn’t revolve around whitetails. Our two Labs make sure of that, and there are days when I gladly grab the Browning Citori – or, if I’m feeling nostalgic, an old Mossberg bolt-action, adjustable choke – and head out for pheasants.
Pennsylvania will never be confused with South Dakota, but we’ve had great days afield and gotten some much-needed exercise along the way.
And heck, I might even grab a fishing rod and hit the Susquehanna River in the heart of archery season for some smallmouth bass that are hopefully in a feeding frenzy.
I honestly enjoy it all.
(Editor’s note: Steve Piatt can be reached via email at stevepiatt04@gmail.com)


