Wednesday, February 1st, 2023
Wednesday, February 1st, 2023

Breaking News for

Sportsmen Since 1967

Lake Michigan gets another hit on carp

Chicago — Was it a bird, was it a plane – or was it a real-life Asian carp?

After scientists discovered DNA from one of the invasive fish in a water sample taken from Lake Michigan’s Sturgeon Bay, sportsmen and fisheries biologists were still unsure if the genetic material came from a live fish or some other source.

What is known is that the sample was the second positive DNA result for Asian carp in Lake Michigan. A sample taken in 2010 from the lake’s Calumet Harbor also was positive.

The most recent red flag comes as DNR, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and a host of others with an interest in protecting the Great Lakes work to figure out how close Asian carp have come to Lake Michigan. Or, how far the fish have advanced toward the lake.

Asian carp are feared for many reasons. Two of the four species of Asian carp – bighead and silver carp – are known to consume large amounts of plankton. Scientists fear if they reach the Great Lakes, they could beat out native species for plankton and other foods and threaten the lakes’ fishing industry, which some value at nearly $7 billion. The effects would trickle across the states that border the Great Lakes, including Illinois.

Plenty of money and effort have been spent defending the lake over the past five years. An electric barrier was installed in a shipping canal 37 miles from Chicago to prevent the carp from progressing north.

One live Asian carp has been found past the barrier.

While DNA from fish commonly comes from their body waste, some biologists and fisheries experts have pointed out that droppings of birds that have eaten Asian carp could also have created the positive

DNA test. Because the DNA sample was taken in Wisconsin waters, that state’s DNR is also looking for answers to “how, when, and where?”

“It’s hard to know what to make of it,” Mike Staggs, director of fisheries management for the  Wisconsin DNR, said.

The samples were collected and analyzed by researchers with the University of Notre Dame, Central Michigan University, and The Nature Conservancy as part of a broader Great Lakes fish survey.

The USFWS indicated that additional samples will be taken from the same area where the positive DNA was discovered. The hope is that the sample was a fluke – a one-time wonder.

“One sample is a smoke detector,” said Chris Jerde, a Notre Dame biologist. “A couple of more samples is a fire.”

The positive test caused a flurry of activity among lawmakers from the Great Lakes states. Sen. Debbie Stabenow, a Michigan Democrat, said the result underscores “the need for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to expedite proposals for permanently shielding the Great Lakes from Asian carp.”

“These fish could destroy the Great Lakes ecosystem, as well as boating and fishing industries and hundreds of thousands of jobs,” Stabenow said.

Staggs, who is skeptical of a live carp being in the lake, said the federal testing that resulted in the positive DNA sample was part of a fish survey of more than 800 various ports across the U.S.

“They ran two tests on the sample, a standard test and then a more sensitive test that did not find it,” he said. “I’m really skeptical there’s an Asian carp out there.”

Share on Social


Hand-Picked For You

Related Articles